Latest News | Canadian Health Supplement Information & Costco Must-Buy Recommendations

Executive Summary: A Game Between Regulation and Risk

In today's booming global e-commerce landscape, consumers have access to health products across borders. For Hong Kong residents and local consumers living in Canada, the choice between purchasing products with NPNs (Natural Product Numbers) from local pharmacies (such as Shoppers Drug Mart and Costco) or buying them from the US e-commerce platform iHerb is no longer just a matter of price, but a game of balancing regulatory philosophy, risk tolerance, and biochemical needs.

This report aims to provide readers of www.canadahk.com.hk with a comprehensive, authoritative, and down-to-earth analysis, delving into the fundamental differences between Health Canada and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in their regulation of health supplements.

The report's core findings point out that the lack of NPNs for iHerb products is not simply an administrative oversight, but stems from a fundamental difference in the two countries' definitions of "supplements": Canada considers them a subset of drugs, requiring proof of safety and efficacy before they can be marketed; while the United States considers them a subset of food, adopting a more lenient "market first, regulate later" strategy.

1. Introduction: Biological and Bureaucratic Game Along National Borders

For many Hong Kong residents who have immigrated to Canada, daily health care presents vastly different choices. When consumers see the wide array of supplements on iHerb, ranging from expensive to inexpensive, they often wonder: "Why can't I find these products on Canadian shelves?" "Why don't iHerb bottles have that NPN number?" "Will these things be confiscated at customs if I buy them?"

The answers to these questions lie hidden in the decades-long regulatory battle between the two major regulatory agencies in North America—Health Canada and the U.S. FDA.

2. A clash of regulatory philosophies: Canada's NPN vs. the US FDA

To understand product differentiation, one must first understand the rule-makers. Canada adopts the "precautionary principle," while the United States follows the "free market principle."

2.1 Canada's protective barrier: Natural Product Number (NPN)

In Canada, all retail natural health products must obtain an NPN (National Registration Number). This is not just a registration number; it is a government endorsement of safety, effectiveness, and quality .

Legal Compulsory: It is illegal to sell any health supplement without an NPN in a Canadian brick-and-mortar store. This explains why you can't find most of the popular US brands available on iHerb at Shoppers Drug Mart.

Canada implements a pre-market assessment system , classifying health supplements as a special category of "drugs." Manufacturers must submit documentation proving their product complies with monographs or provide clinical data before marketing.

2.2 The U.S. Open Strategy: DSHEA and FDA

The United States defines supplements as a subset of "food" based on the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA).

The United States employs post-market surveillance . The FDA does not conduct pre-market approval; manufacturers only need to ensure product safety before releasing the product. The FDA only intervenes after an incident occurs. This is why US products innovate rapidly and have high dosages, but the risks are relatively transferred to consumers.

3. Debunking the Myth: Why does iHerb, a big brand, lack NPN?

Since NPN stands for security, why don't the highly rated big brands on iHerb (such as Life Extension and Thorne) have NPN?

3.1 The nature of parallel imports

iHerb sells US versions of its products. To obtain an NPN (Network Product Number), these brands must redesign their packaging (add French), adjust their formulations (reduce dosage to meet Canadian standards), and pay an application fee. Many US brands believe the Canadian market is too small to justify this and therefore sell only through cross-border e-commerce.

iHerb utilizes the "personal import" exemption, meaning these products never legally "enter" the Canadian retail market and therefore do not require an NPN.

3.2 iTested of iHerb

To compensate for the lack of regulatory oversight, iHerb launched the iTested program, commissioning third-party labs to conduct tests and publish reports. For savvy consumers, this transparency sometimes even surpasses a system that only provides NPNs (Network Notices) without public reporting.

4. The Battle of Ingredients: Dosage Differences Between Vitamin D and Melatonin

The differences in regulations ultimately manifest in the content of a single capsule. Below are some of the significant differences in products commonly purchased by Hong Kong residents.

4.1 Vitamin D: 2500 IU (red line)

Health Canada has set the upper limit for over-the-counter vitamin D supplements at 2500 IU . Any dose exceeding this is considered a prescription drug. However, on iHerb (in the US), you can easily find products with doses of 5000 IU or even 10000 IU.

4.2 Melatonin

Canada stipulates a maximum daily dose of 10 mg , with a preference for synthetic sources. The US market, however, is flooded with potent products at 20 mg or higher, as well as various multi-dose formulations.

4.3 5-HTP and GABA

5-HTP requires a "serotonin syndrome" warning label in Canada. GABA regulation in Canada is more complex; many affordable GABA products commonly found in the US cannot be registered and marketed in Canada due to a lack of sufficient historical records.

5. Prohibited Boundaries: Be careful not to accidentally buy "prohibited items" and have them seized by customs.

The most concerning issue isn't dosage, but legal classification. Some of iHerb's best-selling products may be prescription drugs in Canada.

5.1 Yohimbine: A Hidden Danger in the Fitness World

Yohimbe is a legal fat-burning ingredient in the US, but a prescription drug in Canada. Health Canada considers the risk of side effects too high. Purchasing products containing Yohimbe is the most common reason for customs to seize iHerb packages.

5.2 DHEA: The Myth of Anti-Aging and the Legal Red Line

DHEA is readily available in the United States, but it is a controlled substance/prescription drug in Canada. The legal risks of importing DHEA are far greater than those of ordinary violations.

6. Logistics and Taxes: How to safely "shop" your way back to Canada?

6.1 The Myth of "90-Day Supply"

Canadian residents can import a 90-day supply of NHP for personal use, provided that the product does not contain prescription drug ingredients or regulated ingredients .

Key pitfall: If a bottle of high-dose vitamin D (such as 10,000 IU) on iHerb is defined as a "prescription drug" in Canada, then it is illegal for residents to import it by mail, even if you only buy one bottle.

6.2 Customs Duties and Taxes

• Courier : Duty-free allowance CAD $150, sales tax-free allowance CAD $40.
• Canada Post : The tax-free allowance is usually only CAD $20.

iHerb typically uses the DDP (Delivered Duty Paid) model, where GST/HST is prepaid at checkout. Although taxes must be paid, customs clearance is fast.

7. Economic Analysis: Which is more cost-effective, buying locally or using iHerb?

7.1 Advantages of local shopping (Shoppers, Costco)

• Promotional offer : Take advantage of the "Buy 1 Get 1 Free" offer, where basic vitamins are even cheaper than iHerb.
• Security : Absolutely no risk of being detained by customs, with NPN protection.

7.2 Advantages of iHerb

• High-dose products : low cost per milligram.
• Special ingredients : such as PQQ, Ubiquinol, and special forms of magnesium, which are limited in local availability.
• Own brand : extremely high cost performance.

8. Consumer Decision-Making Guide: Down-to-earth Advice

When should I buy it in Canada?

• Basic vitamins (C, low dose D).
• Liquid fish oil with probiotics that require refrigeration (local preservation is better).
• For the elderly and children (NPN labeling provides clear guidance, and the dosage is conservative and safe).
• Urgent.

When should I buy from iHerb?

• The doctor recommends a high dose (e.g., 5000 IU D3).
• Specific functional supplements (brain enhancement, anti-aging).
• Special dietary requirements (vegan, gluten-free).

Lightning protection list (absolutely do not buy these!)

• ❌ Yohimbine
• ❌ DHEA
• ❌ Compound formulas containing the words "Testosterone Booster"
• ❌ Single product with a supply period exceeding 90 days

Conclusion: Be a savvy hybrid consumer

The differences between the health supplement markets in Canada and the United States are essentially reflections of "safety first" versus "freedom first." NPN acts as a dutiful gatekeeper, while iHerb is a giant self-service supermarket.

The smartest approach is to become a hybrid consumer : utilize Canada's strict NPN system to purchase basic daily health supplements, ensuring safety and convenience; simultaneously use iHerb to supplement with higher-end products not available locally, but be sure to avoid customs restrictions. Understanding the rules behind the labels is more important than simply deciphering the labels themselves.